I could not help but comment on today’s news that Star Wars: Legacy will soon join Knights of the Old Republic among the ranks of great Star Wars series from Dark Horse Comics to conclude with issue 50 after being launched amid the great Star Wars comic relaunch of 2006.
(I should note here that I’ve not yet read Legacy: Monster, Part IV, issue 46 of the series, as my order from TFAW.com seems to have disappeared in the mail, which is nothing new around here, it seems.)
In the first half of the ‘00 decade, Star Wars comics were dominated by the ongoing series that later became Republic, the classic era Empire, the anthology Star Wars Tales, and the oddball, digest-sized Clone Wars Adventures. The stories in Tales were hit or miss, with the last few issues and first few often considered the strongest, while the Clone Wars Adventures comics were mostly pointless throwaway stories that amounted to very little for readers other than empty pockets due to their cover price.
What really shined in that era were the Republic comics and their long-running contributions by John Ostrander and Jan Duursema. The Empire series had its moments too, but, quite frankly, it fell flat for many of us (except the last few storylines) because it felt like ground already trod over and over again in the single most story-packed era of the timeline.
During Dark Horse’s big anniversary hubbub, the entire line was shaken up, mostly for the better. Republic ended with the first days after Revenge of the Sith, but one of its last storylines became the basis for the launch of a post-ROTS series known as Dark Times. Empire gave way to a new series that picked up right where it left off, entitled Rebellion. Rather than each being monthly titles, though, these two swapped positions in the schedule to allow for other titles to exist.
Tales vanished with no anthology to replace it, and Clone Wars Adventures disappeared (but has since had a revival of sorts with the digest-sized The Clone Wars comics and Star Wars Adventures series, which are both throwaway stories also with no real “umph” to them, but at least they are full-length stories now).
Into this mix came two fresh new series that turned out to be two of the best Star Wars series to date: Knights of the Old Republic and Legacy.
KOTOR went on to detail the adventures of Zayne Carrick and his comrades in the era between the Tales of the Jedi comics and the Knights of the Old Republic video games. Under scribe John Jackson Miller, the series was always engaging and amusing, even when, after the climactic Vindication storyline, the series continued on to a less climactic end with its 50th issue, wrapping up the Demon storyline. With KOTOR gone, we were happy to see a quote from Randy Stradley of Dark Horse Comics (albeit an old one) that gave us reason not to have to fear that Legacy would end with its 50th issue as well.
Legacy took us into an altogether unexplored era of the saga. We met Cade Skywalker, who seems to be the great-grandson of Ben Skywalker (who is becoming a hero in his own right in Legacy of the Force and Fate of the Jedi), but more importantly we met a galaxy in an entirely new situation with the Sith-Imperial War, a fractured Empire, the Galactic Alliance Remnant, Imperial Knights, and more. It was probably the freshest new Star Wars series since the launch of Tales of the Jedi in 1993.
Lately, Legacy has been ramping up to major new events, including hints of all-out war, engagement between the One Sith’s Empire and an alliance of convenience consisting of the deposed Emperor’s forces, the remnants of the Jedi Order, what’s left of the Galactic Alliance, and our group of heroes, including Cade Skywalker, whose fate is undetermined at this point.
Now, we have learned that Legacy #50, the final portion of the Extremes storyline, will be the series last, as was the case with Knights of the Old Republic.
Realistically, what does this mean for Star Wars comics?
First, it means that the two most engaging Star Wars comic series will have both been canceled within the same year, wiping out two of the most wide-open eras for storytelling, at least for now.
Second, it means, personally, that one of the main reasons I bother to buy comics anymore is gone.
Third, and perhaps most importantly, look at where it leaves the Star Wars comic line from Dark Horse for the moment:
- Dark Times continues. How that series has survived this long is beyond me. Its issues are frequently delayed and, thus far, the storylines have been very disappointing, slow, and laborious to read, even without so many publishing delays. One can only hope that this series will be axed when the current (interminable) Blue Harvest storyline concludes.
- Invasion (for which Rebellion was axed, in part) continues to follow the adventures of our heroes (and new ones) in the already rather full New Jedi Order era, constantly flirting with potential continuity disasters every time it touches upon heroes and situations from the Del Rey novel series.
- The Clone Wars ongoing comic series has ended, and it would seem that the digest-sized companion series has either ended or is on hiatus for the moment. Again, these were all just throwaway stories, given that it’s obvious going into them that they won’t have any real effect on the cartoon series, and the cartoon series and these comics still have too many continuity questions left unanswered to have these stories being taken too seriously.
- Star Wars Adventures, while sometimes containing nifty little stories (Luke Skywalker and the Treasure of the Dragonsnakes, for example), is moving forward, but it is also made up of throwaway stories with no real impact or “use” (for lack of a better term) within the continuity. In that sense, the series is basically a non-issue, if you’ll pardon the accidental pun.
Until the launch of The Old Republic comic series (which is just a reprint of comics already released for free online) or Knight Errant (a new series by KOTOR writer John Jackson Miller that seems to be a glimmer of hope for Star Wars comics), we are basically left with the four weakest titles of the Star Wars publishing line: one of which may not even exist anymore; one of which might as well not exist for its lack of impact; one of which is retreading old ground, at least in part; and the oldest of which is something many fans have been actually hoping would finally be canceled due to sheer lack of interesting characters.
I cannot recall a time in Star Wars comics when prospects for the immediate future were so bleak. Even in the era of new mini-series launching every couple of weeks, we had a larger variety to choose from, upping the odds of getting some really good tales mixed in with the poor offerings. But, really, a Star Wars line that is hanging its hat on the combination of Star Wars Adventures, Invasion, and Dark Times? Is that the best we can hope for until Knight Errant arrives? Color me entirely unimpressed and downright pessimistic.
Here’s hoping that the end of Legacy signals the launch of a new project by Ostrander and Duursema in that era, perhaps further in the future or connecting Fate of the Jedi to Legacy. I truly hope that there is a grand scheme to this decision that is going to blow our socks off that I’m just not privy to. Otherwise, the “new golden age” of Star Wars comics that I have referred to on forums and in podcasts for the last few years has finally come to an end.
So long, Legacy. We hardly knew ye.
This entry was posted on Monday, April 12th, 2010 at 8:27 pm and is filed under The EU Review. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. Both comments and pings are currently closed.
darkness Comics
anthology, empty pockets, hubbub, launch, mail, star wars tales